Ashley's Island House

Contact us

557 Catawba Avenue, Put-in-Bay, Ohio, 43456

  • Welcome to Ashley's Island House!

    "I must say that this was our second experience at Ashley's Island House and it was, once again, a fantastic experience all around. The owners are just out of this world with pleasantness and making people feel welcome. I must say in many ways these trips feel like coming back to a friends house rather than staying at a B&B." - TripAdvisor Review, 2014

    Check Availability »
  • Island History

    "Not only is it a great place to stay and location but the owners are AWESOME" - TripAdvisor Review, 2014

    Submit a Reservation Request »
  • Front Porch View

    "Not only are the owners, Bob and Judy awesome, but their manager Kelly ROCKS. Makes you feel like family when you are there. My husband and I have stayed at Ashleys for the last 10 years!!! This last trip we had 17 people with our group staying at Ashley's and they have ALL booked there for next year. Charming, friendly, great location. It really just doesn't get any better than Ashley's Island House!!! Trust me!!!!" - TripAdvisor Review, 2014

    Check Our Rooms »

Welcome to Ashley's Island House

Thank You for considering staying at Ashleys Island House.   Ashleys Island House is currently taking reservations for the 2022 season. Many of the good weekends are already getting close to selling out.   We will reopen on April 1st for the 2022 season.  
We do not take online reservations. You have to call to make reservations. I can be reached 7 days a week from 9am till 9pm or via text or email. So please email us at ashleysislandhousepib@gmail or text my cell phone at 216-870-3234. Bash at the Bay for 2022  is sold out. 

We do not take children on weekends. They are welcome during the week. 

Ashley's Island House, a Put-in-Bay, Ohio bed and breakfast, extends a warm invitation for you to be our guest and allow the atmosphere of an old country inn, with its feeling of unhurried living, to surround you and create a mood of long ago. We offer a variety of accommodations all of which feature hardwood floors, lofty windows, paddle wheel fans, central heat and air and antique furniture and lighting. Whether you are traveling for business or pleasure, you'll find your lodging needs most comfortably met in a manner that far exceeds that of a typical hotel stay. The island of Put in Bay, OH offers our guests such interesting diversions as fine shops, restaurants, entertainment, churches and other historical buildings to explore in town. Explore the island on foot, or rent a bike or golf cart and enjoy fishing and boating in our beautiful lake. Bring your bathing suit and relax in one of the five public pools nearby.

-Laurie & Dave Schafer, Owners

Ashley's Island House is located one block from downtown Put In Bay. This Historic 1860's Victorian Bed and Breakfast is the largest and oldest on the island. Deluxe continental breakfast is included every day in 2022! All rooms in the house have a queen size bed and a private bathroom. The carriage house is now available to rent for up to 6 people. We are open from April 1 to November 1. And don't forget that we also have golf carts to rent for our guests! Call 419-285-2844 to book today!!!!



  • Nearby Pool
  • Spacious Porch
  • Free WiFi
  • Owners Onsite
  • Continental Breakfast
  • Bicycles
  • Golf Carts
  • Corn Hole Boards
  • Free Ice
  • Spectrum Cable
  • Refrigerator in Pantry
  • Gas Grill
  • Weddings
  • Family Reunions

Our famous rooms